Is Being Given a Coach a Reward or a Warning?

– Ashwni Sharma

Executive coach having a thoughtful development conversation with a senior leader.

“Aah, I think this guy in my team needs coaching. He’s a big problem for the team.”

I still hear this often, and I understand where it comes from.

But it also tells me a lot about how coaching is being used in that organisation.

When coaching is offered only to people who are seen as a problem, the person knows exactly why. Nobody has to say it.

So they come in wanting to explain themselves, and spend the first few sessions proving there is nothing wrong with them. Sometimes longer.

That makes the work much harder than it needs to be. It is difficult to look at yourself honestly when you feel you first have to defend yourself.

But the leaders who often get the most from coaching are already doing well. There may be no visible performance problem at all.

– Someone who is delivering everything asked of them, but still feels something is missing.

– Someone about to take on a much bigger role than anything they have handled before.

– Someone whose numbers are excellent while their team is burning out.

– And someone who has simply run out of people willing to tell them the truth.

That last one deserves more attention than it gets.

The more senior you become, the more this happens. People start choosing their words with you. They stop disagreeing, or you stop hearing about the disagreements.

Everyone becomes professional, respectful and polite…

And slowly, you stop hearing anything real.

Often, no one is deliberately holding back. It just happens gradually. But it leaves you without the honest feedback you need to keep getting better.

Which is why coaching works best when it is offered as an investment in someone, not as a correction.

If a leader believes they are being backed, they walk in curious. If they believe they are being corrected, they walk in careful.

And that changes what they are willing to look at.

So if you are the one deciding who gets a coach, this is the question I would ask:

In your organisation, is being given a coach a reward…or a warning?

Your leaders already know the answer.

And it decides what return you get for the investment.

#ExecutiveCoaching #LeadershipDevelopment #TalentDevelopment #ABrighterLife

Ashwni Sharma

Executive & Leadership Coach ( ICF-PCC → MCC in Progress ) · Marshall Goldsmith Certified · Founder & MD, A Brighter Life

Ashwni, the Founder and MD of A Brighter Life, is dedicated to empowering leaders to enhance their effectiveness, mindfulness, and influence for joyful success. With over 27+ years of corporate experience, driven by his passion for personal transformation, Ashwni left a successful career spanning four major companies across the UK, USA, and India. Working with CXOs, Board Members, and Top Leaders globally, he combines business management skills with life transformation expertise to enable practical and applicable conversations and actions. He holds international certifications as an Executive Coach and has mastered modalities such as NLP and Hypnotherapy. Ashwni’s passion lies in fostering self-leadership as the foundation for leadership development.

Connect with Ashwni Sharma

0 Comments